[page 8]
KRESTINSKY Exeouted KOLLONTAI Sweden STALIN Survivor DZERZHINSKY Dead LENIN Dead
### SMILGA
Executed ZINOVIEV Executed ARTEM Dead BUBNOV Disappeared MILIUTIN Disappeared
### TROTSKY
Assassinated KAMENEV Executed SOKOLNIKOV Imprisoned JOFFE Suicide. TROTSKY BEGINS his analysis by looking at the Communist Party, its Congress and its Central Committee. Without the political and organisational leadership of the Bolshevik Party and its leaders, the revolution of 1917 would not have succeeded.
The Bolsheviks' success stemmed in no small part from the fact that their party was both democratic and centralised. It was highly disciplined and well organised, yet also elected its leadership and conducted democratic debate on political issues. Congresses and Central Committees played a crucial part in maintaining these traditions. They comprised the most politically capable and most tried and tested class fighters from within the party, elected by and answerable to the membership.
Trotsky saw the parallel of the growth of Stalinism in the degeneration of these traditions within the party. While Lenin lived the congresses were held very regularly every year between the sixth Congress of 1917 and the twelth in 1923. The next year, the congress was held a month late. In 1925, it was sixth months late. The gap steadily widened from two years between 1925 and 1927 to five years, between 1934 and 1939, when Trotsky was writing...
... This prolongation of time intervals was of course no accident. In the years of the revolution and the civil war the party found it possible to adhere to its own statutes; the Central Committee remained an organ subject to the control of the party. The Central Committee began to rise above the party simultaneously with the rise of the Soviet bureaucracy over the workers' state. The control of the party, however terrorised, became an irksome fetter for the Central Committee. The intervals between the congresses were henceforth determined to an ever larger measure by the administrative exigencies of the ruling nucleus in the Central Committee, that is, Stalin's clique. Thus, the fourteenth congress (in 1925) was convened after a half year's delay in connection From with the internal struggle in the "triumvirate" (Stalin, Zinoviev, Kamenev). Before presenting himself at the congress, Stalin had to make sure of his majority in the provinces. It was no longer a question of solving controversial issues, nor of exercising control over the CC, but of setting the seal of approval on accomplished facts. The fifteenth congress (in 1927) was convened for the sole purpose of drawing the balance sheet of the strangulation of the Left Opposition. The time for its convocation was determined by this very task. An identical task was fulfilled by the sixteenth congress(in 1930), this time in relation to the Right Opposition. The seventeenth congress (in 1934) was called only after the crisis in collectivisation had passed its acutist phases and the CC was already in position to report certain "consoling" items. Finally, the eighteenth congress (in 1939) was convened after the purges of Yagoda, Yezhov, and Beria had succeeded in rooting out opposition, terrorising the party, and reconstituting the ruling apparatus in the state and the army. The interrelationship between the party and the apparatus has been stood completely on its head...
Committee Trotsky turns to the Central Committee, describing how in the Bolshevik era its composition relfected "years of work, testing and selection. " The replacement of older members by younger forces was carried out in such a way that a stable nucleus remained. During the first seven congresses after the revolution, the same nucleus was retained with only a few new Molotov, the prete element then Si selectio.
After of CC n betweer to 71. A shuntin to be fc minate ...The March ‹ from tl percent sonnel preceed ed the I Joint ( Right C the coI Stalin's consist three -or just people' As al • Voroshilov and Stalin escorting 1 ext for the start of the Moscow ts being brought on and ubjected to testing and • 1923, however, the number nembers began to rise from 7 15 and 27 to 40 and later Uter 1927, there began "the g aside of Old Bolsheviks", illowed by a drive to exterthem physically... eighteenth congress held in of this year (1939) took over he outgoing CC only 22.5 of its members! The perof the CC which in the ling eleven years had smasheft Opposition and then the Opposition and then the Opposition, and had secured mplete "monolithism" of ; party thus proved to have ted of more than quarters traitors, betrayers, : plain " enemies of the example we take the Cenaway. In the Soviet Union the state has become enormously re-inforced.
[page 9]
Victory in the second world war led to a further strengthening of the bureaucracy. Its material privileges grew-fat salaries, holiday villas, cars, special shops, special schools for their children.
As waste and corruption rose to almost Czarist levels, the bureaucracy moved from being a relative fetter on an economy which was still expanding faster than in any capitalist country, to an absolute fetter on economic development. With no control by the masses, and all power concentrated at the top of the bureaucratic machine, the economy has only grown very But its domination of Russian society canot last indefinitely. Inevitably the working class will move in the direction of political revolution. They will demand a return to the kind of society envisaged by Lenin and Trotsky. With the development of industry, automation and electronics, a sixhour day and a four-day week would be possible immediately. Living stanIt would be possible now to add to Lenin's four points, the right of all political parties to operate freely, as a check against any return to Workers in Britain and throughout the world. even members of the "communist" parties, overwhelmingly reject totalitarianism. But they need to understand the history of Stalinism in order to make certain that there is no repetition. Trotsky's greatest contribution to the workers' movement ws his explanation of the causes of Stalinism, which enable workers today to purges In the years of hardship which followed the 1917 revolution, a young commissar talks to peasants who were so poor that some had resorted to eating the flesh of those who had died. Economic backwardness and the defeat of revolutions in the advanced countries created the conditions for the rise of e coffin of Kirov, the Leningrad party leader, whose assassination in 1934 was esser leaders during the revolution . He used that position to provide politically. paratus of both the party and the ky described this period as "Thertion which followed the French r-revolution was taking place. d in 1940 was murdered by Stalin's italin launched an offensive against ed him build his power base. This tion of agriculture during which ite; the entire bureaucracy was in le Old Bolsheviks whose very exembarked on the trials, to try and in from those who had played any gument, still popular in academic of Bolshevism. He illustrates how us of totalitarian repression, not Jists, but to defend the privileges nism was a negation of Bolshevism nination af any trace of Bolshevik iety the state would begin to wither re crushed ils. tral Committee that was elected in August 1917 and led the October Revolution. This historical staff slowly.
dards could rise to undreamed-of levels.
totalitarianism.
learn the lessons of history.
October Revolution was the handiwork of the agents of the German general staff... nucleus in the interval between the congresses. Changes in the personnel of the CC are effected through the state apparatus, or to put it more correctly, through certain "secret" departments of this apparatus, above all the GPU. Among the staff of seventy-one members of the incumbent CC there is Beria, the head of the GPU, and Vyshinsky, former chief prosecutor, now Molotov's deputy. Beria's past in the party is at best an obscure one. Vyshinsky's past in the party is quite clear: he adhered to Menshevism in the 'heroic" periods of his career, at a time when it was impossible not to belong to a "leftist" party; but for the most part he was an attorney for the oil trust. He appeared on the Soviet arena during tie period of the crushing of the Trotskyist opposition. This individual did not become a Bonapartist lackey; he was born such. Stalin leans not upon the CC but on Beria, Vyshinsky, and their assistants in whose presence the ordinary members of the CC quake...
Political Bureau ...The Central Committee as a Stalinism.
as a more or less stable piece of decoration. It wields no power. In contrast to the CC, the Political Bureau is composed predominantly of Old Bolsheviks. Of them, Stalin alone served as a member of the Political Bureau under Lenin; Kalinin was for a while a candidate. The majority of the remaining members, men like Molotov, Andreyev, Voroshilov, Kaganovich, Mikoyan are by no means youngsters whose talents bloomed in the recent period. They were sufficiently well known fifteen and even twenty years ago; but it was precisely for this reason that the idea never entered anyone's mind that these people were capable of leading the party. They are kept in the Political Bureau primarily because in the guise of "Old Bolsheviks" they provide a species of cover for shysters of the Vyshinsky-Beria-Potemkin-et al. type. On every important question Stalin confronts his "Political Bureau" with an accomplished fact.
To sum up, we can draw two extremely important conclusions:
1. What is now being designated as party "monolithism" has acquired a social and political content which is the diametrical opposite of Bolshevism. A genuine Bolshevik party prides itself on its unanimity but only in the sense that it groups the vanguard of the workers on the basis of an irreconcible revolutionary programme. The party demarcates itself from all other tendencies along the line of the pro22 February 1985 MILITANT 9 layers. The principal methods of this adaption are the dictatorial purges. The monolithism of the party signifies today not its unity on the basis of the proletarian programme but its docility to the apparatus that betrays this programme. Renewals in the personnel of the CC have reflected and continue to reflect the social shift of the party from the oppressed to the oppressors.
### Mortal enemies
2. The second conclusion is indissolubly linked with the first. The unimpeachable language of figures mercilessly refutes the assertion so current among the democratic intellectuals that Stalinism and Bolshevism are "one and the same". Stalinism originated not as an organic outgrowth of Bolshevism but as a negation of Bolshevism consummated in blood. The process of this negation is mirrored very graphically in the history of the Central Committee. Stalinism had to exterminate first politically and then physically the leading cadres of Bolshevism in order to become what it now is: an apparatus of the privileged, a brake upon historical progress, an agency of world imperialism. Stalinism and Bolshevism are mortal enemies.
----- pull-quotes -----
A Graphic History of Bolshevism