Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Stalinism and Bolshevism

No. 737, 22 February 1985 · pp. 9-10 of the scan · 540 words

The scan: Militant 737 1985-02-22.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 2.6x body type, 2 line(s), left edges within 0.002.

[page 9]

consisted of twenty-one members. Of them only one remains at the present time in the party leadership-Stalin. Seven have died of disease or have fallen at the hands of the enemy (we shall not engage in a dispute over the causes). Shot or condemned to the firing squad-seven; three have disappeared during the purges; three others have been liqudated politically-and perhaps alse physically: a total of thirteen, that is, almost 62 percent of the participants in the October staff turned out to be "enemies of the people". Stalin here provides a statistical confirmation sui generis of the hoary theory of MiliukovKerensky (leaders of the capitalist governments which ruled Russia between the February and October revolutions in 1917—ed) that the Similar proportions of those elected to the CC at later congresses were physically and politically liquidated—63.5%, 70%, 76% and 67.6% of those elected at the 10th, 15th, 16th and 17th congresses respectively.

We cannot tell as yet just how or to what extent the incumbent CC will be extirpated, but its horoscope is a dark one..

...The changes in the composition of the CC were accompanied by even more drastic changes in its role. The old Bolshevik CC was the undisputed leader of the party and was most conscientious in its attitude toward questions of theory and the voice of the workers. The incumbent CC has no independent meaning whatever. It is handpicked as an auxiliary to the ruling nucleus, and it is altered by the committee is a many-headed myth. It goes without saying that the most important questions, such as purging the CC itself, cannot even be discussed in the Committee, inasmuch as 32.4 percent of its members cannot possibly pass a decision to destroy 67.6 percent. Such questions are decided by the super-Central Committee of StalinYagoda-Yezhov-Vyshinsky. The fate of the party depends as little on the CC as the fate of the latter does on the party.

The Political Bureau, in its turn, does not at all depend on the CC. This is most glaringly demonstrated in the fact that the Political Bureau has undergone relatively little change in the Stalinist era, while the CC "electing" it has been periodically subjected to extermination. But this immutable Political Bureau serves itself only letarian class struggle. The Stalinist party has the following characteristic trait: there is a systematic shift away from proletarian politics toward the policy of defending the privileged layers (the kulak (rich peasant), the Nepman (would-be capitalist—ed), the bureaucrat, in the first period; the bureaucrat, the labour and Kolkhoz (collective farm) aristocracy, in the second period). This social shift is intimately bound up with the recasting of the entire programme in both domestic as well as world politics (the theory of socialism in one country, the struggle against equality, the defence of imperialist democracy, People's Fronts, etc.) The ruling apparatus systematically adapts the party and its institutions to this changing programme, that is, in the service of new and ever more privileged social Marxist Studies Read more about the growth of Stalinism in this pamphlet. Price 50p (inc. post and packing) from World Socialist Books, 3 - 13 Hepscott Road, London E9 5HB. See also ad on page 13.

[page 10]

10 MILITANT 22 February 1985•

← Stalin'sBangladesh : year of the workers →

Something wrong on this page?